Greetings! I'm here to suggest my first ever suggestion on MCTrades hopefully it'll get accepted! So basically, everyone is pretty pissed off from the Rule = 1.18 You may not request any user(s) for vouches, reputation, or reactions directly. It might need a couple edits. So, if I give someone a Vouch Copy or dealt with before, means I can't ask for a vouch? So loosing money to give a Vouch Copy and he doesn't like vouch for me or forgets.. Or dealt with someone before and made alot of deals with him, you can't ask for a vouch? Imo, this rule needs to be edited, whoever is with me, just react with the 'Agree' reaction to show how much we need this! Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
-1 If you clearly state its a vouch copy, and give it to someone that's actually reputable they will provide a vouch without needing to be asked. The rule is in place for a reason and I personally am thankful it's here, it's so easy for someone to give out like 20 alts, ask for positive reputation each time and then use this to look reputable and could easily exit scam.
How about if the VC needs to be something valuable, ex: You can't give an Alt VC, something worth over $2 or so? Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
As I said, only give VC's to people who know who they are and you can see have taken VC's before and provided a vouch when the product works. Instead of asking for a vouch, it's not hard to ask them for a little bit of feedback so other buyers know the product is working.
Still, someone still wants to build his reputation Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
Then just keep selling legit products and people who are thankful tend to leave a vouch, anytime I sell something I receive a vouch and rep without asking, same happens with basically everyone, just be patient and dont expect rep from every sale.
I have never seen a rule like this before, it's not the best rule.. They could work something else to replace this rule... Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
It's perfectly fine and reasonable, everyone does have their own opinion but I believe it is more beneficial than anything.
The biggest Minecraft Marketplaces never had this rule, and everything is prefectly fine! Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
Because alts on there aren't sold, as I've previously stated, not hard to sell 1 alt to 20 different people and ask for rep to seem more reputable than someone actually is, then could very easily exit scam for a much larger amount.
How about MCSell Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
It doesn't, but it was a succesful Marketplace, and never had such a rule. Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
And had a ton of scammers on it and only used a similar reputation system for a very short amount of time.
Not really, if you know how to deal with scammers, it'll be easy for you to be there. Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
A couple of members are not, that's why I created it, if you don't support this, just leave a disagree. Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
I agree. If I sell someone 100 SFAs or whatever it may be and they don't vouch or forget to vouch, I ask them to do so as that's the only way to gain reputation. I don't see why I shouldn't ask for a quick vouch on my profile seeing as I just sold them legitimate accounts. Banned Reason: Scamming https://mctrades.org/threads/tiger-steven-dispute.2203/ Ban Ends: Never
Thanks for your reply, thats my point too! Banned Reason: Scamming #3324 (HugeSpeed) - Original Ban: [ Projecki, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:00 PM ] Ban Ends: Never
